• Recent Posts

  • Recent Comments

    Dani Renan on Who Said God Is Dead?
    Goose on Who Said God Is Dead?
    Judah Rosen on Can Water Bring Peace?
    Judah Rosen on Six Days & Fifty Year…
    Gus on Six Days & Fifty Year…
  • Top Posts

  • Search by Category

  • Archives

  • Blog Stats

    • 11,829 hits
  • Pages

  • Twitter

  • Meta

How the Jews Saved the World

coffeeshoprabbi.com

coffeeshoprabbi.com

A nagging, persistent thought regarding the Second World War and the Holocaust won’t leave me in peace. It’s been bothering me, or shall I say been challenging me, for a long time. And it seems like the right time now, with Yom HaShoah (Holocaust Day) upon us on May 5th, for me to formulate my thoughts on the matter. Indeed, as a son of Holocaust survivors, who sucked the Shoah from his mother’s breast (so to speak), and who grew up in a kibbutz in Israel where, literally, there were no grandparents, I thought it is high time for me now to finally dedicate a post to this most terrible event in our history.

First problem for me in doing so is that – especially regarding this specific topic, or the angle I want to explore here – I’m not a historian, though student of history I most certainly am. As well, I don’t consider myself a scholar of the Holocaust, though I definitely have read my share of books on the Shoah, have seen many films about it, and have heard many people talk about it. Second problem is, as much as I searched and googled, I could find no record, or study, a book even, anything that deals with what I am about to write here, or at least suggesting that particular point of view. If by any chance you, the reader, know more about it, or know of such a book or a research, please don’t hesitate to comment here, and enlightened me about it.

To the point. There are many studies as to Hitler’s origin as a man, and his hatred of the Jews in particular. There are equally many theories, too, but no definite answer – almost akin to the question of who came first, the chicken or the egg – as to what came first: Hitler pathological hatred of the Jews, seeing Jewish conspiracy in everything from capitalism to communism, or his megalomaniacal wish to conquer Europe and the world. In other words: conquer the world in order to annihilate the Jewish People, or annihilate the Jewish People in order to conquer the world? From what little I know, I believe the former to be the correct answer. I believe that in Hitler – who had Jewish blood in him, according to some (unconfirmed) accounts – the hatred for the Jews ran deeper. I also believe that his first calling and career ambition was to be an artist; he blamed the Jews and their prominence in the world of art, particularly in Vienna, for his failure as an artist. (He was rejected twice by the Academy of Fine Arts Vienna, as “unfit for painting”.) You know how it goes today, the “Jews control the Media.” Then it was the “Jews control the Arts”.

We know that Hitler was not even “pure German,” was not even “pure Arian,” by look or by ancestry; and yet, to an “artistic” degree and performance he assumed – and indeed conquered – this persona and identity. One has to see again, as I had done not so long ago, Charlie Chaplin’s masterpiece, “The Great Dictator” – remember the hilarious scene where Hitler plays with the globe as if it were an air balloon? – in order to understand the magnitude of his ambition in this regard, and the resemblance of the characteristics at play in his personality. It makes sense, therefore, to theorize that Hitler’s anti-Semitism, and his urge for revenge – that most brutal, and persistent of human tendencies – came first. And of course, he couldn’t have executed his masterplan of annihilating the Jews before governing and ruling Germany and Europe first. And there lay his ultimate failure and demise.

Think about it: He had accomplished, to an extraordinary degree, the initial stages of his plan. He created (or recreated) a political party; he won the elections democratically (there were obstacles along the way, of course, which had only made his resolved stronger); he established a dictatorship over “supposedly” the most culturally advanced people and nation in Europa at the time; he had built a tremendous war machine, unequal up till then; he maneuvered skillfully as head of state to push Britain and Russia aside for the time being; he had started a war which went very well, and according to plan for him, for more than two years. He was controlling most of Europe when he decided to conquer Russia as well, and at the initial stages was successful there too.

What went wrong then? I believe it was his obsession with annihilating and exterminating the Jews. Of course, there was Britain and Churchill, America and Roosevelt (not clear still, when and if, America would’ve joined the war had it not been for the attack on Pearl Harbor); and the Russian winter and Stalin pushed into a corner. Many reasons, for sure. But I’m here writing to suggest that crucial among these factors, and maybe the most decisive of all, was his obsession with the Jews. And that the cost of annihilating the Jews had cost him winning the war.

On the one hand, think about the enormous effort – personnel wise, resources wise, time wise, money wise, military wise – he had put into exterminating the Jews (and of course other minorities too along with them). Building concentration camps, sending trains full of people to crisscross Europe back and forth, exterminating them, guarding them, sometimes fighting against them when they rebelled and took arms. It was an enormous effort and strain on the German people, army, economy, and war machine. It would’ve been simpler just shooting them amass. Instead, had he used all these soldiers and officers, and had he directed these resources toward the war, particularly in Russia (which he too late had tried to do), it might have given him then a decisive advantage and victory.

On the second hand, had he used the Jewish people to his advantage, even if not willingly, his chances of success would’ve been much greater. Just keeping all the great Jewish scientists and engineers in Germany, not forcing them to flee the country, enslaving them or killing them, might have given him the Atom Bomb first. Who knows what would have happened then. Just thinking about it, Hitler possessing a nuclear weapon, makes me shudder. But instead, they built it for America. Yes, able Jews were sent to labor camps – as was the case with my father, who slaved at, and escaped from three of them – but had it been done without the hatred, in a “patriotic” fashion, they would’ve joined the fighting forces, the commanding echelon, the economic war effort, contributing their financial and professional strength. It may be hard to believe and accept, but even after the horrors of the Holocaust, in my kibbutz, those who came from Germany, escaping the purges and war ahead of time, still cherished its “culture” and language very much.

As I was saying from the outset, I’m not a historian. But it seems to me that among all the factors contributing to Hitler’s defeat, his obsession with the “Final Solution” of the Jews was indeed decisive. Had it not been for that, and for the urge to annihilate all the Jews, the story of Europe – indeed of the world – would’ve been very different. But then again, he couldn’t help it. His obsession with them ran deeper than anything else. And his obsession with not just killing them, but exterminating them, probably killed his chances of winning the war and conquering the world. In that respect, as of course in many others, we should be thankful to all the victims of the Holocaust and their survivors. They died and suffered so that we can live and prosper. They saved us all.

* The “Leave a Comment” link is the last tag below, in blue.

Advertisements

One Response

  1. Yikes. You are most assuredly entitled to your opinions, but that one is a doosey. It’s about as non-PC as saying that the Jews in Europe should have fought back instead of walking into those trains. The reasons why they were not able to resist is as complex as peace in the Mideast. No,,,,,, the real answer is that Hitler’s Germany was destined to fail because America was going to enter the war, with or without Pearl Harbor, and we would eventually crush them. His biggest mistake was turning on Russia. If not for that critical mistake Hitler’s Germany could have held on to Western Europe for a very long time and killed every European Jew instead of only half of them. Please note that I blame more than Hitler. One final thing, I get that many people don’t believe in G-d. But based on the numerous books I have read, I am convinced it was G-d that made Hitler just insane enough to make wrong choices for the critical decisions that led to the end of the Third Reich. Think about that one,,,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: